Constraint Pre-Flight Verification

Prevents the "implemented but not registered" bug where constraints are created, tested, and exported but never added to the ConstraintManager factory methods.

Two Truths: Constraints Affect Prescriptive Layer

CRITICAL CONTEXT:

Truth Type	Tables	Constraint Role
Prescriptive	rotation_templates, weekly_patterns, constraints	Define what SHOULD happen
Descriptive	half_day_assignments	Record what DID happen

Constraints are part of the prescriptive layer. They define rules that the solver uses to transform templates into assignments.

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                   PRESCRIPTIVE LAYER                            │
│  rotation_templates + weekly_patterns + CONSTRAINTS             │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
                              │
                              ▼ expansion_service + solver
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                   DESCRIPTIVE LAYER                             │
│                   half_day_assignments                          │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Impact of constraint changes:

• Adding/modifying constraints changes prescriptive truth
• Changes only take effect after RE-GENERATING the schedule
• Existing half_day_assignments won't auto-update - you must regenerate

Testing implication:

• Test constraints against template expectations (prescriptive)
• Verify generated assignments reflect constraint behavior (descriptive)

When This Skill Activates

• When creating new scheduling constraints
• When modifying existing constraints
• Before committing constraint-related changes
• When the user asks to verify constraint registration
• After adding constraints to __init__.py exports

The Constraint Gap Problem

What Goes Wrong

A common failure mode in constraint development:

1. Create constraint class in backend/app/scheduling/constraints/*.py  ✓
2. Write tests for constraint logic                                     ✓
3. Export constraint in __init__.py                                     ✓
4. Tests pass locally                                                   ✓
5. ⚠️ FORGET to register in ConstraintManager.create_default()         ✗
6. Commit and push                                                      ✓
7. Schedule generation doesn't use the constraint!                      💥

Why It Happens

• Tests verify constraint logic in isolation
• Tests don't verify the constraint is actually used by the scheduler
• Manual verification of "registered at line X" is error-prone
• No CI check catches unregistered constraints

Pre-Flight Verification Script

Run this before committing any constraint changes:

cd /home/user/Autonomous-Assignment-Program-Manager/backend
python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

What It Checks

1. Registration - All exported constraints are in ConstraintManager.create_default()
2. Weight Hierarchy - Soft constraint weights follow documented order
3. Manager Consistency - Constraints in both create_default() and create_resilience_aware()

Expected Output

============================================================
CONSTRAINT PRE-FLIGHT VERIFICATION
============================================================
This script verifies constraint implementation completeness.
Run this before committing constraint changes.

============================================================
CONSTRAINT REGISTRATION VERIFICATION
============================================================

Registered constraints (23 total):
  - 1in7Rule: ENABLED
  - 80HourRule: ENABLED
  - Availability: ENABLED
  - CallSpacing: ENABLED weight=8.0
  - ClinicCapacity: ENABLED
  ...

Block 10 Constraint Check:
  [OK] CallSpacingConstraint
  [OK] SundayCallEquityConstraint
  [OK] TuesdayCallPreferenceConstraint
  [OK] WeekdayCallEquityConstraint
  [OK] ResidentInpatientHeadcountConstraint
  [OK] PostFMITSundayBlockingConstraint

============================================================
WEIGHT HIERARCHY VERIFICATION
============================================================

Call equity weight hierarchy:
  [OK] SundayCallEquity: weight=10.0
  [OK] CallSpacing: weight=8.0
  [OK] WeekdayCallEquity: weight=5.0
  [OK] TuesdayCallPreference: weight=2.0

============================================================
MANAGER CONSISTENCY VERIFICATION
============================================================

Block 10 constraints in both managers:
  [OK] ResidentInpatientHeadcount
  [OK] PostFMITSundayBlocking
  [OK] SundayCallEquity
  [OK] CallSpacing
  [OK] WeekdayCallEquity
  [OK] TuesdayCallPreference

============================================================
SUMMARY
============================================================
  Registration: PASS
  Weight Hierarchy: PASS
  Manager Consistency: PASS

[SUCCESS] All verifications passed!

Constraint Development Checklist

When creating a new constraint:

Step 1: Implement Constraint Class

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/my_constraint.py

class MyNewConstraint(SoftConstraint):
    """
    Docstring explaining the constraint's purpose.
    """
    def __init__(self, weight: float = 5.0) -> None:
        super().__init__(
            name="MyNewConstraint",
            constraint_type=ConstraintType.EQUITY,
            weight=weight,
            priority=ConstraintPriority.MEDIUM,
        )

    def add_to_cpsat(self, model, variables, context) -> None:
        # CP-SAT implementation
        pass

    def add_to_pulp(self, model, variables, context) -> None:
        # PuLP implementation
        pass

    def validate(self, assignments, context) -> ConstraintResult:
        # Validation implementation
        pass

Step 2: Export in __init__.py

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/__init__.py

from .my_constraint import MyNewConstraint

__all__ = [
    # ... existing exports ...
    "MyNewConstraint",
]

Step 3: Register in Manager (CRITICAL!)

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py

from .my_constraint import MyNewConstraint

class ConstraintManager:
    @classmethod
    def create_default(cls) -> "ConstraintManager":
        manager = cls()
        # ... existing constraints ...
        manager.add(MyNewConstraint(weight=5.0))  # ADD THIS!
        return manager

    @classmethod
    def create_resilience_aware(cls, ...) -> "ConstraintManager":
        manager = cls()
        # ... existing constraints ...
        manager.add(MyNewConstraint(weight=5.0))  # ADD THIS TOO!
        return manager

Step 4: Write Tests

# backend/tests/test_my_constraint.py

from app.scheduling.constraints import MyNewConstraint, ConstraintManager


class TestMyNewConstraint:
    def test_constraint_initialization(self):
        constraint = MyNewConstraint()
        assert constraint.name == "MyNewConstraint"
        assert constraint.weight == 5.0

    def test_constraint_registered_in_manager(self):
        """CRITICAL: Verify constraint is actually used!"""
        manager = ConstraintManager.create_default()
        registered_types = {type(c) for c in manager.constraints}
        assert MyNewConstraint in registered_types

Step 5: Run Pre-Flight Verification

cd backend
python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

Step 6: Commit Only If All Pass

git add .
git commit -m "feat: add MyNewConstraint for [purpose]"

Test Coverage

The test_constraint_registration.py file provides automated CI coverage:

# Key tests that prevent the registration gap:

class TestConstraintRegistration:
    def test_block10_hard_constraints_in_default_manager(self):
        """Verify hard constraints are registered."""

    def test_block10_soft_constraints_in_default_manager(self):
        """Verify soft constraints are registered."""

    def test_call_equity_weight_hierarchy(self):
        """Verify weights follow: Sunday > Spacing > Weekday > Tuesday."""


class TestConstraintExportIntegrity:
    def test_all_call_equity_exports_registered(self):
        """All exported classes must be in manager."""

    def test_inpatient_constraint_registered(self):
        """ResidentInpatientHeadcountConstraint is registered."""

Quick Commands

# Run pre-flight verification
cd backend && python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

# Run constraint registration tests only
cd backend && pytest tests/test_constraint_registration.py -v

# Run all constraint tests
cd backend && pytest tests/test_*constraint*.py -v

# Check manager.py for registrations
grep -n "manager.add" backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py

Key Files

File	Purpose
scripts/verify_constraints.py	Pre-flight verification script
backend/tests/test_constraint_registration.py	CI tests for registration
backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py	Where constraints are registered
backend/app/scheduling/constraints/__init__.py	Where constraints are exported

Weight Hierarchy Reference

For call equity constraints, follow this hierarchy (highest impact first):

Constraint	Weight	Rationale
SundayCallEquity	10.0	Worst call day, highest priority
CallSpacing	8.0	Burnout prevention
WeekdayCallEquity	5.0	Balance Mon-Thu calls
TuesdayCallPreference	2.0	Academic scheduling preference
DeptChiefWednesdayPreference	1.0	Personal preference (lowest)

Workflow Diagram

┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│            CONSTRAINT PRE-FLIGHT WORKFLOW                        │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                  │
│  STEP 1: Implement Constraint Class                             │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ Create class in constraints/*.py               │             │
│  │ Implement: __init__, add_to_cpsat,             │             │
│  │            add_to_pulp, validate                │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                         ↓                                        │
│  STEP 2: Export in __init__.py                                  │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ Add import statement                           │             │
│  │ Add to __all__ list                            │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                         ↓                                        │
│  STEP 3: Register in ConstraintManager (CRITICAL!)              │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ Import in manager.py                           │             │
│  │ Add to create_default()                        │             │
│  │ Add to create_resilience_aware()               │             │
│  │ ⚠️ MUST BE IN BOTH FACTORY METHODS             │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                         ↓                                        │
│  STEP 4: Write Tests                                            │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ Unit tests for constraint logic                │             │
│  │ Registration test in manager                   │             │
│  │ Integration test with scheduler                │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                         ↓                                        │
│  STEP 5: Run Pre-Flight Verification (MANDATORY)                │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py        │             │
│  │ ✓ Registration check                           │             │
│  │ ✓ Weight hierarchy check                       │             │
│  │ ✓ Manager consistency check                    │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                         ↓                                        │
│  STEP 6: Commit Only If All Pass                                │
│  ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────┐             │
│  │ All verifications PASS                         │             │
│  │ Tests PASS                                     │             │
│  │ → Safe to commit                               │             │
│  └────────────────────────────────────────────────┘             │
│                                                                  │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Concrete Usage Example: Adding FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint

Scenario: Program director wants to minimize Friday call assignments to improve weekend coverage.

Complete Implementation Walkthrough

Step 1: Implement the Constraint Class

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/friday_call_avoidance.py

"""Soft constraint to minimize Friday call assignments."""

from typing import Any, Dict, List
from app.scheduling.constraints.base import SoftConstraint, ConstraintResult
from app.scheduling.constraints.types import ConstraintType, ConstraintPriority


class FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(SoftConstraint):
    """
    Minimize Friday inpatient call assignments to improve weekend coverage.

    Clinical rationale: Friday call often extends into Saturday coverage,
    reducing resident availability for weekend shifts.

    Weight: 3.0 (medium-low priority, below call equity constraints)
    """

    def __init__(self, weight: float = 3.0) -> None:
        super().__init__(
            name="FridayCallAvoidance",
            constraint_type=ConstraintType.PREFERENCE,
            weight=weight,
            priority=ConstraintPriority.MEDIUM,
        )

    def add_to_cpsat(
        self, model: Any, variables: Dict[str, Any], context: Dict[str, Any]
    ) -> None:
        """Add penalty for Friday call assignments in CP-SAT solver."""
        # Implementation details...
        pass

    def add_to_pulp(
        self, model: Any, variables: Dict[str, Any], context: Dict[str, Any]
    ) -> None:
        """Add penalty for Friday call assignments in PuLP solver."""
        # Implementation details...
        pass

    def validate(
        self, assignments: List[Any], context: Dict[str, Any]
    ) -> ConstraintResult:
        """Validate Friday call distribution."""
        # Implementation details...
        pass

Step 2: Export in init.py

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/__init__.py

from .friday_call_avoidance import FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint

__all__ = [
    # ... existing exports ...
    "CallSpacingConstraint",
    "SundayCallEquityConstraint",
    "TuesdayCallPreferenceConstraint",
    "WeekdayCallEquityConstraint",
    # NEW:
    "FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint",  # ← Add this!
]

Step 3: Register in ConstraintManager (CRITICAL!)

# backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py

from .friday_call_avoidance import FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint

class ConstraintManager:
    @classmethod
    def create_default(cls) -> "ConstraintManager":
        """Create manager with standard constraint set."""
        manager = cls()

        # ... existing constraints ...

        # Call equity constraints (weight hierarchy matters!)
        manager.add(SundayCallEquityConstraint(weight=10.0))
        manager.add(CallSpacingConstraint(weight=8.0))
        manager.add(WeekdayCallEquityConstraint(weight=5.0))
        manager.add(TuesdayCallPreferenceConstraint(weight=2.0))

        # NEW: Add Friday avoidance (weight=3.0, below call equity)
        manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # ← Add this!

        return manager

    @classmethod
    def create_resilience_aware(
        cls,
        n1_compliant: bool = True,
        utilization_cap: float = 0.8,
        defense_level: int = 2,
    ) -> "ConstraintManager":
        """Create manager with resilience-aware constraints."""
        manager = cls()

        # ... existing constraints ...

        # Call preferences
        manager.add(SundayCallEquityConstraint(weight=10.0))
        manager.add(CallSpacingConstraint(weight=8.0))
        manager.add(WeekdayCallEquityConstraint(weight=5.0))
        manager.add(TuesdayCallPreferenceConstraint(weight=2.0))

        # NEW: Add here too!
        manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # ← And this!

        return manager

Step 4: Write Tests

# backend/tests/test_friday_call_avoidance.py

import pytest
from app.scheduling.constraints import (
    FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint,
    ConstraintManager,
)


class TestFridayCallAvoidanceConstraint:
    def test_constraint_initialization(self):
        """Verify constraint initializes with correct values."""
        constraint = FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint()
        assert constraint.name == "FridayCallAvoidance"
        assert constraint.weight == 3.0
        assert constraint.constraint_type == ConstraintType.PREFERENCE

    def test_custom_weight(self):
        """Test constraint with custom weight."""
        constraint = FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=5.0)
        assert constraint.weight == 5.0

    def test_constraint_registered_in_default_manager(self):
        """CRITICAL: Verify constraint is in create_default()."""
        manager = ConstraintManager.create_default()
        registered_types = {type(c) for c in manager.constraints}
        assert FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint in registered_types

    def test_constraint_registered_in_resilience_manager(self):
        """CRITICAL: Verify constraint is in create_resilience_aware()."""
        manager = ConstraintManager.create_resilience_aware()
        registered_types = {type(c) for c in manager.constraints}
        assert FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint in registered_types

    def test_validate_friday_distribution(self):
        """Test validation logic for Friday call assignments."""
        # Implementation...
        pass

Step 5: Run Pre-Flight Verification

cd /home/user/Autonomous-Assignment-Program-Manager/backend

# Run verification script
python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

Expected Output:

============================================================
CONSTRAINT PRE-FLIGHT VERIFICATION
============================================================

============================================================
CONSTRAINT REGISTRATION VERIFICATION
============================================================

Registered constraints (24 total):  # ← Was 23, now 24
  - 1in7Rule: ENABLED
  - 80HourRule: ENABLED
  - Availability: ENABLED
  - CallSpacing: ENABLED weight=8.0
  ...
  - FridayCallAvoidance: ENABLED weight=3.0  # ← NEW!

Block 10 Constraint Check:
  [OK] CallSpacingConstraint
  [OK] SundayCallEquityConstraint
  [OK] TuesdayCallPreferenceConstraint
  [OK] WeekdayCallEquityConstraint
  [OK] FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint  # ← NEW!

============================================================
WEIGHT HIERARCHY VERIFICATION
============================================================

Call preference weight hierarchy:
  [OK] SundayCallEquity: weight=10.0
  [OK] CallSpacing: weight=8.0
  [OK] WeekdayCallEquity: weight=5.0
  [OK] FridayCallAvoidance: weight=3.0  # ← NEW! Correctly positioned
  [OK] TuesdayCallPreference: weight=2.0

============================================================
MANAGER CONSISTENCY VERIFICATION
============================================================

Block 10 constraints in both managers:
  [OK] FridayCallAvoidance  # ← In both create_default() and create_resilience_aware()

============================================================
SUMMARY
============================================================
  Registration: PASS ✓
  Weight Hierarchy: PASS ✓
  Manager Consistency: PASS ✓

[SUCCESS] All verifications passed!

Step 6: Run Tests and Commit

# Run tests
pytest tests/test_friday_call_avoidance.py -v
pytest tests/test_constraint_registration.py -v

# All pass? Commit!
git add backend/app/scheduling/constraints/friday_call_avoidance.py
git add backend/app/scheduling/constraints/__init__.py
git add backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py
git add backend/tests/test_friday_call_avoidance.py

git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
feat: add FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint to minimize Friday calls

Implements soft constraint (weight=3.0) to reduce Friday inpatient
call assignments, improving weekend coverage availability.

- Constraint registered in both default and resilience-aware managers
- Weight positioned below call equity (5.0) but above Tuesday preference (2.0)
- Verified with pre-flight check and registration tests
EOF
)"

Failure Mode Handling

Failure Mode 1: Constraint Not Registered

Symptom:

$ python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

[ERROR] FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint exported but NOT registered in ConstraintManager!

Root cause: Forgot Step 3 (registering in manager.py)

Recovery:

# 1. Add to manager.py
from .friday_call_avoidance import FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint

# 2. Add to BOTH factory methods
def create_default(cls):
    manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # Add this!

def create_resilience_aware(cls, ...):
    manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # And this!

# 3. Re-run verification
python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py
# Should now PASS

Failure Mode 2: Weight Hierarchy Violation

Symptom:

$ python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

[WARNING] Weight hierarchy violated:
  SundayCallEquity: 10.0
  CallSpacing: 8.0
  FridayCallAvoidance: 9.0  ← TOO HIGH! Should be < 8.0
  WeekdayCallEquity: 5.0

Root cause: Weight set too high, violating call equity hierarchy

Recovery:

# 1. Adjust weight in manager.py
# OLD:
manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=9.0))  # Wrong!

# NEW:
manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # Correct

# 2. Document rationale
# Weight must be < 5.0 (below WeekdayCallEquity)
# but > 2.0 (above TuesdayCallPreference)
# because Friday avoidance is more important than day preference

# 3. Re-run verification
python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

Failure Mode 3: Missing from One Manager

Symptom:

$ python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py

[ERROR] Manager consistency check FAILED:
  FridayCallAvoidance in create_default() ✓
  FridayCallAvoidance in create_resilience_aware() ✗ MISSING!

Root cause: Added to create_default() but forgot create_resilience_aware()

Recovery:

# Add to BOTH methods:
@classmethod
def create_resilience_aware(cls, ...):
    manager = cls()
    # ... other constraints ...
    manager.add(FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint(weight=3.0))  # ← Add this!
    return manager

Failure Mode 4: Tests Fail Despite Correct Code

Symptom:

$ pytest tests/test_constraint_registration.py -v

FAILED test_constraint_registered_in_default_manager
AssertionError: FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint not in registered types

Root cause: Test ran before constraint was imported in manager

Recovery:

# 1. Verify import exists in manager.py
grep "FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint" backend/app/scheduling/constraints/manager.py

# 2. If missing, add import:
from .friday_call_avoidance import FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint

# 3. Clear Python cache
find . -type d -name __pycache__ -exec rm -rf {} +
find . -type f -name "*.pyc" -delete

# 4. Re-run tests
pytest tests/test_constraint_registration.py -v

Integration with Other Skills

With automated-code-fixer

Scenario: Pre-flight fails, automated-code-fixer can add registration

[constraint-preflight detects missing registration]
→ "FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint exported but not registered"

[Invoke automated-code-fixer]
→ automated-code-fixer adds manager.add() lines to both methods
→ Re-runs verification
→ All checks PASS
→ Commits fix

With test-writer

Workflow:

[User creates new constraint class]
[constraint-preflight activated]

Step 1-3: Implement, export, register
Step 4: Invoke test-writer skill

"Generate comprehensive tests for FridayCallAvoidanceConstraint:
- Initialization tests
- Registration tests
- Validation logic tests
- Weight hierarchy tests"

[test-writer generates test suite]
[constraint-preflight verifies tests cover registration]

With code-review

Pre-commit integration:

[About to commit constraint changes]
[constraint-preflight runs verification]
→ All checks PASS

[Invoke code-review skill]
→ Reviews constraint implementation
→ Checks weight rationale is documented
→ Verifies clinical justification in docstring
→ Approves or requests changes

[Commit only after both skills approve]

With pr-reviewer

PR workflow:

[PR created with new constraint]
[pr-reviewer activated]

→ Detects constraint-related changes
→ Invokes constraint-preflight automatically
→ Runs verification in CI
→ Includes verification output in PR review:

"Constraint Pre-Flight Check: PASS ✓
- Registration verified
- Weight hierarchy correct
- Manager consistency confirmed"

Validation Checklist

Pre-Implementation Checklist

• Constraint purpose is clear and documented
• Clinical/operational rationale defined
• Weight determined relative to existing constraints
• Decided if hard or soft constraint
• Identified which managers need registration

Implementation Checklist

• Constraint class created with all required methods
• Docstring explains purpose and rationale
• Exported in __init__.py
• Imported in manager.py
• Added to create_default()
• Added to create_resilience_aware() (if applicable)
• Weight documented with justification

Testing Checklist

• Unit tests for constraint logic
• Registration test in default manager
• Registration test in resilience manager (if applicable)
• Weight hierarchy test (for soft constraints)
• Integration test with scheduler
• All tests PASS

Verification Checklist

• Run python ../scripts/verify_constraints.py
• Registration check: PASS
• Weight hierarchy check: PASS
• Manager consistency check: PASS
• Run pytest tests/test_constraint_registration.py -v: ALL PASS
• Run full test suite: ALL PASS

Pre-Commit Checklist

• All verification checks PASS
• All tests PASS
• No linting errors
• Weight rationale documented in code
• Clinical justification in docstring
• Ready to commit

Escalation Checklist

Escalate to human if ANY of these are true:

• New constraint category (not equity/preference/workload)
• Weight hierarchy decision needs clinical input
• Affects ACGME compliance rules
• Conflicts with existing constraints
• Requires new solver techniques
• Pre-flight verification fails with unclear errors

Escalation Rules

Escalate to human when:

1. Pre-flight verification fails with unclear errors
2. Weight hierarchy decisions need clinical input
3. New constraint category needs architectural review
4. Constraint affects ACGME compliance rules